SIM Swap Fraud costs BSNL over ₹55 lakh as Karnataka High Court holds the telecom operator liable after fraudsters steal ₹87.7 lakh from a bank.
|
SIM Swap Fraud has put BSNL in trouble after the Karnataka High Court ordered the telecom operator to pay over ₹55 lakh in compensation to a cooperative bank. The bank lost ₹87.7 lakh after fraudsters obtained a duplicate SIM card and used it to access banking OTPs. The ruling sends a clear warning to telecom companies: careless SIM replacement can carry a heavy financial cost.
According to The Hindu, the case involved Sri Basaveshwara Pattana Sahakara Bank Niyamitha in Karnataka. Fraudsters obtained a duplicate SIM linked to the bank's registered mobile number from a BSNL office in Bengaluru without proper authorization. They then used the number to receive OTPs and carry out seven unauthorized RTGS and NEFT transactions between February 6 and 7, 2019.
How did one duplicate SIM open the door to ₹87.7 lakh in fraudulent transfers?
The bank recovered ₹30 lakh through reversed transactions and another ₹7.12 lakh through police efforts. However, ₹50.50 lakh remained unrecovered. The Karnataka High Court held BSNL responsible for failing to verify the request before issuing the replacement SIM.
Justice Suraj Govindaraj made the telecom operator's responsibility clear. He observed, "The duty is particularly heightened when the subscriber is a banking institution that has registered the mobile number for OTP-based authentication of high-value financial transactions."
The judge also pointed to the failure in verification, stating, "The very fact that a duplicate SIM reached a non-subscriber is proof that verification was either not conducted, or was conducted in so perfunctory a manner as to be worthless."
Under the order, BSNL must pay ₹50,50,762 for the bank's financial loss and an additional ₹5 lakh in consequential damages, with 9% annual interest from February 7, 2019.
Can telecom operators continue issuing replacement SIM cards without stronger identity checks?
The case also highlights the need for better fraud detection. A GSMA study on Airtel's security measures explains how network APIs can alert banks to SIM swaps and device changes, helping them flag suspicious activity before approving transactions.
Business Honor observes that the Karnataka High Court ruling makes one issue difficult to ignore: banking security does not rest with banks alone. Telecom operators control access to mobile numbers that receive financial OTPs. If they fail to verify replacement requests, customers and financial institutions can pay the price. The decision could push telecom providers to treat SIM security as a financial responsibility rather than a routine service procedure.
FAQs
What is SIM Swap Fraud?
SIM Swap Fraud occurs when criminals obtain a duplicate SIM linked to another person's mobile number and use it to intercept banking OTPs.
Why did the Karnataka High Court hold BSNL liable?
The court found that BSNL failed to verify the duplicate SIM request properly, allowing an unauthorized person to access the bank's registered mobile number.
How much compensation must BSNL pay?
BSNL must pay ₹50.50 lakh for the bank's financial loss and ₹5 lakh in consequential damages, along with 9% annual interest.
How much money was stolen in the SIM Swap Fraud case?
Fraudsters carried out seven unauthorized transactions worth ₹87.70 lakh. The bank's unrecovered loss stood at ₹50.50 lakh.
How can telecom companies prevent SIM Swap Fraud?
They can enforce strict identity checks, verify SIM replacement requests and use network APIs to alert banks about suspicious SIM changes.































.webp)
Comments
0 Comments